Making the world a reason-free zone 5

To be religious, to believe in a creator god or divine being of any description, is not intellectually respectable.

Far from deserving respect, religions deserve scorn. And worse. The histories of most of them warrant intense abhorrence.

What prompts us now to utter such blunt, unqualified, hard assertions on this “sensitive” subject? This report, which tells how Muslims are trying to make the whole world a reason-free zone.

We quote from the website of Jonathan Turley:

The effort by Muslim countries to curtail free speech in the name of their religion continues. While the Obama Administration has sought to appease these countries in developing an international blasphemy standard, this case shows how even the more modern Islamic countries (as well as Western countries) are finding blasphemy to be a useful vehicle to control speech and silence critics.

The latest attack comes from Qatar which has proposed a ban that would allow for the prosecution of people in other countries. That’s right, our allies are creating laws to allow them to prosecute people for insulting religion outside their own countries.

The use of the term “defamation” is a new twist to satisfy Western sensibilities and make it sound like this is a recognized form of legal action. However, it is the old blasphemy law in a new and more menacing form. The law would actually be broader than blasphemy which already exists on the books of many Muslim countries. This law would allow for the prosecution of people for all forms of defamation. Derision or denigration of religions and prophets will be considered crimes.

The selling point of the new law was explained by Ebrahim Mousa Al Hitmi, the Qatari justice ministry assistant undersecretary for legal affairs,“The main feature of the draft is that it gives every state the right to put on trial those who abuse and hold in contempt religions even if they are outside the country.”

However this “legal expert” assured people that there is no danger at all to free speech because insulting religion is not protected speech:

The law does not interfere in any way with the freedom of opinion and expression which is well protected and guaranteed. All penal laws in Arab countries criminalize defamation of religions but there are no specific sanctions when an abuser is outside the country. Therefore, the main goal of this law is to deter all forms of defamation of religions and give each country that ratifies it the right to file lawsuits against those who offend religions, even if they are not residents.

See how simple it is? You first declare denigrating religion as outside of the scope of permitted speech and then when you prosecute people for writing or speaking about religion it is by definition not a question of free speech.

These laws reflect an inherent insecurity among religious extremists running these countries that free speech represents a serious threat to orthodoxy. It is not enough that they prosecute and even execute people for apostasy. They are determined to cut off alternative views being spoken about religion on the Internet or in other countries. …

There can be no compromise between free speech and blasphemy. These nations stand against the most basic right of all men and women to speak freely and worship (or not worship) as their values dictate.

Of course the Muslims mean that only their own religion must not be criticized. They will continue to “defame” all other religions – and atheism – and obey their own doctrinal commandment to convert, subdue, or kill non-Muslims whenever they can.

And it may be impractical for them to enforce this decision outside their own areas of jurisdiction. But Europe is already complying with it. The Obama administration is sympathetic to it. And some US judges have already decided cases in accordance with sharia law, and a supreme court judge has argued in favor of doing so.

Those who hold the conviction that all ideas – including and especially religious ideas – should be continually and forever examined in the the light of reason, beware!

And stand your ground.


(Hat-tip for the report, our reader Frank)

  • liz

    This is the Mother of all hypocrisy. Laws demanded against blaspheming religion by those who not only blaspheme all other religions, but kill those who practice them! The equivalent of crocodiles demanding a law among herbivores against pointing out predators at the watering hole.
    Only blind cretins would fall for such an obvious pretense, or those who are complete hypocrites themselves, such as Obama.

  • Ron G

    In my fantasy-land, the president says, “Yes, we agree, you should make those laws.” When they are passed he says, “Now we are going to ignore you and make fun of you even more.”

    • Jillian Becker

      A consoling fantasy, Ron G. But not this president. He loves Islam.

      • Ron G

        A guy can dream…


    (quote) “And some U.S. judges have already decided cases in accordance with sharia law, and a supreme court judge has argued in favor of doing so.”
    This unprecedented and unbelievable position by some legal “minds” could be the beginning of the end for our personal freedom, if we as a voting block do not prick up our collective ears, and are not more cautious, IMHO.

    The problem raised by any sort of belief system like religion, (pick any one you want to) is the absolute adherence to dogmatic regimentation that is required by the Bible’s and the Quran’s laws that the Priests and Mullahs must, by the same laws follow to a “T,” and administer to their flock. Most of these religious leaders don’t follow these laws as they were originally laid out, since all but the most radical believers would simply leave, in a hurry.

    The Christian Bible has some interesting passages which call for stoning folks to death, beatings, murders for working on the sabbath, etc., yet nearly the entirety of Christianity doesn’t follow these tenets, and hasn’t for hundreds of years. The Quran is equally guilty of the same atrocities within it’s pages.

    The almost universal dismissal of these horrendous laws written thousands of years ago in both books, allegedly by the “Hand of God,” give meaning to the radical Muslim’s and Christian’s causes, who will denounce and occasionally attack those not obeying the atrocious side of their favorite book, as the “infidels.”

    And so people…..good, innocent, loving people, die in the Name Of The Lord……just as well as those “faithful servants” who carry out the murderous way of life dictated by these two books of religion….whether his name is Jesus, God, Yahweh, or Allah.